Frequently Asked Questions

Florida Insurance Claim FAQs

Have questions about a Florida property insurance claim? Homeowner Claims Help (HCH) answers common questions about public adjusters, denied and underpaid claims, roof and water damage, insurance claim deadlines, property insurance appraisals, umpires, mediation, and expert witness services.

Whether you are considering filing a claim, disputing an insurance company’s estimate, or trying to resolve an existing claim, these answers explain important options available to Florida property owners.

HCH has assisted Florida property owners since 2013, with more than 5,000 property inspections and damage evaluations. We serve Tampa Bay and handle appropriate property insurance matters throughout Florida.

Florida Public Adjusters and Insurance Claims

1. What does a public adjuster do in Florida?

A Florida public adjuster represents a policyholder in preparing, documenting, presenting, and negotiating a property insurance claim. Unlike an insurance company adjuster, who represents the insurer, a public adjuster works on behalf of the insured.

Depending on the assignment, a public adjuster may inspect property damage, review the insurance policy, prepare a damage estimate, document repair requirements, communicate with the insurance company, and negotiate disputed claim amounts.

Public adjusters are licensed and regulated in Florida under Florida Statute §626.854.

Learn more about HCH’s Florida public adjusting services.

2. When should I hire a public adjuster for a property insurance claim?

You may consider hiring a public adjuster when damage is extensive, the insurance company’s estimate appears incomplete, the claim has been denied or underpaid, or you need help documenting and negotiating a property loss.

You do not necessarily have to wait until the insurance company makes a decision. A public adjuster may be able to assist earlier, depending on the circumstances and applicable licensing requirements.

Common reasons homeowners seek assistance include:

  • The insurance estimate does not include all documented damage.
  • The proposed repair scope is incomplete.
  • The contractor’s estimate is substantially higher than the insurance estimate.
  • Hidden damage is discovered during repairs.
  • Code-related or construction requirements affect the necessary repair work.
  • The insurance company denies, delays, or disputes the claim.

HCH public adjusting services help policyholders evaluate and document disputed property insurance claims.

3. Can I hire a public adjuster if my insurance claim was denied or underpaid?

Yes. A Florida policyholder may seek assistance reviewing a denied or underpaid property insurance claim. The review may include the insurer’s coverage position, policy provisions, inspection findings, photographs, estimates, and other claim documentation.

An independent evaluation may identify overlooked damage, differences in repair scope, estimating errors, or other issues that warrant further consideration. Whether additional insurance benefits are available depends on the policy, evidence, and applicable law.

HCH assists with denied, delayed, and underpaid claims involving residential and commercial properties.

Read more about public adjusting in Florida or review HCH property insurance case studies and client reviews.

4. What if my contractor’s estimate is higher than the insurance company’s estimate?

A difference between a contractor’s estimate and an insurance company’s estimate does not automatically establish that either amount is correct. The estimates should be compared to determine whether they address the same damage, measurements, materials, labor, and repair operations.

Disagreements may involve missing damage, incomplete repair scope, omitted construction operations, material requirements, labor costs, or applicable building-code requirements.

HCH can review the documented damage and compare competing estimates to identify the specific differences affecting the amount of loss.

Learn about public adjusting and property insurance appraisal services.

5. Can I file a homeowners insurance claim before hiring a contractor?

Generally, yes. A homeowner does not ordinarily have to hire a contractor before reporting property damage to the insurance company. The policy may require prompt notice of a loss and compliance with other post-loss obligations.

A contractor’s inspection or estimate may help document the damage and anticipated repairs, but homeowners should not assume they must wait for a contractor before notifying their insurer.

If you discover potential storm damage, water intrusion, or other property damage and are unsure whether to file a claim, HCH can discuss the circumstances and explain the available claim-assistance services.

Contact HCH to discuss a potential Florida property insurance claim.

Florida Insurance Claim Deadlines and Public Adjuster Fees

6. How long do I have to file a property insurance claim in Florida?

Florida Statute §627.70132 establishes notice deadlines for property insurance claims. Under the current statute, an initial claim or reopened claim generally must be reported within one year after the date of loss. A supplemental claim generally must be reported within 18 months after the date of loss.

The statute distinguishes a reopened claim from a supplemental claim. A reopened claim involves a previously closed claim for additional costs related to damage already disclosed. A supplemental claim involves additional loss or damage from the same peril under the statutory definition.

These deadlines are subject to the statute’s terms and applicable circumstances. Policyholders should not assume that a claim can be reported at any time or that an exception automatically applies.

Review Florida Statute §627.70132 and consult a qualified professional about the requirements applicable to your loss.

7. Can I reopen or supplement a previously paid Florida insurance claim?

Depending on the circumstances, a policyholder may be able to request additional consideration of a previously reported property loss. This may involve a reopened claim or a supplemental claim, which are distinct terms under Florida law.

Additional damage may become apparent during repairs, or a review of the original inspection and estimate may identify damage or repair costs that were not previously addressed.

Florida Statute §627.70132 establishes different notice periods for reopened and supplemental claims. The applicable deadline depends on the type of claim and date of loss.

HCH can evaluate the available claim documentation, inspect property damage when appropriate, and review differences between the original insurance estimate and the documented loss.

Read the Florida claim-notice statute or contact HCH to discuss your circumstances.

8. How much does a public adjuster charge in Florida?

Public adjuster fees are generally established in a written contract and are subject to Florida’s statutory compensation limits. The permitted compensation depends on the type of claim, the circumstances in which the contract is entered, and whether the matter involves a reopened or supplemental claim.

Florida Statute §626.854 establishes restrictions on public adjuster compensation, including specific limitations for certain reopened and supplemental claims. A public adjuster’s fee cannot simply be assumed to be the same for every claim.

Before signing an agreement, review the fee calculation, services being provided, cancellation provisions, and other contract terms.

See Florida Statute §626.854 for the applicable requirements. Contact HCH for information about the services and written agreement applicable to your situation.

9. How long does an insurance company have to respond to a Florida property insurance claim?

Florida law establishes deadlines for insurers to acknowledge communications, investigate claims, and make claim determinations or payments. The applicable requirements depend on the type of claim, the relevant event, and the circumstances affecting the investigation.

Florida Statute §627.70131 addresses insurer claim-handling requirements, including timeframes for acknowledging communications and making claim determinations or payments. Certain circumstances may affect or toll statutory time periods.

Policyholders should retain copies of claim notices, correspondence, document requests, inspection records, and payment decisions.

Read Florida Statute §627.70131.

Florida Property Insurance Appraisal and Umpire Services

10. What is the appraisal process in a Florida property insurance claim?

Property insurance appraisal is a dispute-resolution process that may be available under an insurance policy when the policyholder and insurer disagree about the amount of a property loss.

Each party generally selects an appraiser. The appraisers inspect and evaluate the disputed damage, review estimates and supporting documentation, and attempt to reach an agreement. If they cannot agree, the unresolved differences may be submitted to an umpire under the policy’s appraisal procedure.

Appraisal generally addresses the amount of loss, not every question concerning insurance coverage. The policy’s appraisal clause determines the applicable procedure and requirements.

Learn more about Florida property insurance appraisal services.

11. What types of insurance disputes can be resolved through appraisal?

Depending on the policy language and applicable law, appraisal may address disagreements involving the amount of a property loss, including:

  • The extent and scope of documented property damage.
  • Repair methods and replacement requirements.
  • Measurements, quantities, and materials.
  • Labor and construction costs.
  • Differences between competing repair estimates.
  • Omitted operations and disputed repair items.

Appraisal does not automatically resolve every coverage dispute. Questions involving policy exclusions, coverage determinations, or other legal issues may require separate consideration.

HCH provides appraisal services involving residential, commercial, condominium, and HOA property disputes. Visit our appraisal services page.

12. What is the difference between an appraiser and an umpire?

An appraiser is selected by one party to participate in the insurance appraisal process. The appraiser evaluates the amount of loss and presents that party’s position in accordance with the applicable policy and professional obligations.

An umpire is the neutral third participant who becomes involved when the two appraisers cannot agree on the disputed issues. The umpire evaluates the unresolved differences and participates in determining the appraisal award under the policy.

Daniel Jama, CPAU, accepts appointments as both a party-appointed appraiser and a neutral umpire. Each appointment is subject to a conflict check and review of the applicable policy provisions.

Learn more about HCH’s appraisal and umpire appointments.

13. Is a Florida property insurance appraisal award binding?

Many property insurance policies provide that an appraisal award becomes binding when signed by any two of the three participants: the two appraisers and the umpire. The actual requirements depend on the policy language and applicable law.

An appraisal award generally addresses the amount of loss submitted through the appraisal process. It does not necessarily resolve separate coverage disputes, policy interpretation issues, or other matters outside the scope of appraisal.

The specific appraisal clause should always be reviewed before determining the effect of an award.

For professional appraisal or umpire appointments, visit HCH’s appraisal and umpire services page.

14. Can an insurance appraisal umpire be challenged in Florida?

Florida Statute §627.70151 identifies specific grounds for challenging an umpire’s impartiality and disqualifying a proposed umpire in covered residential property insurance appraisal matters.

The statute addresses certain familial relationships, prior professional representation involving the same claim or property, materially adverse interests in substantially related matters, and recent employment relationships with a party.

The statute’s application depends on the type of policy and appraisal proceeding. It should not be treated as a universal rule governing every insurance appraisal.

Read Florida Statute §627.70151 and learn about HCH’s appraisal and umpire services.

Florida Property Insurance Mediation

15. What is Florida property insurance mediation?

Florida property insurance mediation is a dispute-resolution process in which a neutral mediator helps the policyholder and insurance company discuss disputed claim issues and explore a possible settlement.

The mediator facilitates communication and negotiations but does not decide the amount the insurance company must pay. Mediation is generally nonbinding unless the parties reach a written settlement that becomes binding under the applicable program requirements.

Florida Statute §627.7015 establishes an alternative procedure for resolving certain disputed property insurance claims.

Read Florida Statute §627.7015 or visit the Florida Department of Financial Services mediation information page.

16. What is the difference between property insurance appraisal and mediation?

Appraisal and mediation are two different ways of addressing property insurance disputes.

Appraisal is generally used to resolve disagreements about the amount of a property loss when the insurance policy provides for the process. The parties select appraisers, and an umpire may become involved if the appraisers cannot agree.

Mediation involves a neutral mediator who helps the parties discuss their positions and attempt to reach a voluntary settlement. The mediator does not impose a decision or determine the amount owed.

The appropriate process depends on the nature of the dispute, policy language, program eligibility, and applicable law. For example, Florida’s residential property mediation program has eligibility requirements and generally operates before appraisal or litigation.

Explore appraisal services and Florida property insurance mediation.

HCH Experience and Expert Witness Services

17. What experience does Homeowner Claims Help have with Florida property insurance claims?

Homeowner Claims Help was founded in 2013 and has worked with Florida property owners on residential and commercial insurance matters involving property damage, claim documentation, appraisal, and dispute resolution.

Daniel Jama, SCLA, CPAU, has personally conducted more than 5,000 property inspections and damage evaluations. His professional background includes construction and roofing, carrier-side claims adjusting, public adjusting, appraisal, and umpire work.

This experience provides practical insight into how property damage is inspected, estimated, documented, and disputed from different perspectives in the insurance claim process.

Read more about HCH’s case studies and client reviews or visit the Florida property insurance expert witness page.

18. Does HCH provide property insurance expert witness services?

Yes. HCH provides property insurance expert witness services for qualified matters involving property damage, construction issues, repair methods, estimating disputes, claim documentation, and insurance claim practices.

Daniel Jama, SCLA, CPAU, accepts qualified engagements from plaintiff and defense counsel, law firms, and insurance carriers. Depending on the assignment, services may include independent file review, technical analysis, expert reports, examinations under oath, depositions, and trial testimony.

Florida’s expert testimony standard is addressed in §90.702, Florida Statutes. The statute requires sufficient facts or data, reliable principles and methods, and reliable application of those methods to the facts of the case. The court determines admissibility.

Read Florida Statute §90.702 and learn more about HCH’s expert witness services.

19. Does HCH serve homeowners and commercial property owners throughout Florida?

Yes. HCH is based in the Tampa Bay area and handles appropriate property insurance matters throughout Florida.

Service areas include Pasco, Pinellas, and Hillsborough counties, as well as other Florida locations depending on the type of assignment and services required.

HCH works on residential, commercial, condominium, and HOA property matters. Services may include public adjusting, appraisal, umpire appointments, mediation-related assistance, and expert witness engagements.

Contact HCH to discuss your property location and the services appropriate for your matter.

Need Help With a Florida Property Insurance Claim?

Whether your insurance claim has been denied, underpaid, delayed, or involves a disagreement over the amount of damage, Homeowner Claims Help can review the circumstances and explain which services may be appropriate.

Homeowner Claims Help (HCH)
Tampa Bay and statewide Florida

Phone: 727-657-6193
Email: claims@hchflorida.com

Contact HCH

The information on this page is provided for general educational purposes only. It is not legal advice, a coverage determination, or a guarantee of insurance benefits. Insurance claims are governed by the applicable policy, facts, and Florida law. Deadlines, eligibility, and dispute-resolution procedures may vary by claim and circumstance.